Around France

American in France: French Healthcare, Part 2

I fell while crossing the street in Aigues-Mortes, France. I broke my hip and shoulder on the right side. Since then, I’ve sampled how healthcare is delivered, French style. (American in France: French Healthcare: Part 1)

As crazy as it might seem, several years ago in the US, I experienced an almost identical injury to the one in France. Except it was on my left side. This post is about my US healthcare experience.

The accident eight years ago happened in my home in South Carolina. I had just separated from my husband of 40 years, so I was alone. As I had been warned not to do many times during my marriage, I was standing on top of the kitchen counter. I fell off.

“Why was I standing on the kitchen counter? ” you ask. My most popular answer is “pole dancing.” Believe as you will.

When I fell from the countertop onto the tile floor in the kitchen, I landed on my left side. Immediately I knew I was in trouble. My left leg was crooked at a 45-degree angle. My left arm was killing me. I was nauseous.

No one was around except my labradoodle, Bentley, so I had to find my cell phone to call for help.

But where was the phone?

In my foggy state, I remembered I had last used the cell phone in the living room. I dragged myself on the floor to find it. Fortunately, it was where I thought I’d left it. I called my sister-in-law, who was in the same town.

The next thing I remember, a strange man was kneeling over me, calling my name. I had passed out. The man was an EMT. With the aid of another EMT, he lifted me onto what felt like a board. My leg was still bent. I was in excruciating pain.

When we arrived at the hospital emergency room, my brother, sister-in-law, and ex-husband were there. They took care of the details of admitting me to the emergency room while I was wheeled into a “holding area.”

As I remember, it was close to 9pm when I entered the hospital’s emergency room. After X-rays and the sad discovery that I had broken my hip and arm, I was put into my private room. It was after 4am. Apparently, the hospital had a problem locating the doctor. Without his approval, they could not admit me.

Fortunately, I was loaded with meds, so I was in and out of consciousness. I remember vividly, however, when they put me in the hospital bed and forced my leg down straight with a pulley and weights. That hurt big time.

US Healthcare: Surgery and Post Op

My hip was operated on the second day I was in the hospital. Three pins were inserted through a tiny incision to hold the break in the hip. No surgery was needed for the broken bone in my arm. Just a bandage.

Five days after I was admitted, I was discharged from the hospital.

US Healthcare: Rehab

Whenever I’ve been hospitalized for surgery in the US, I’ve been asked, “Is there anyone at home who can care for you?” Don’t ask me why no one mentions a stop at a rehabilitation hospital.

In fact, I know of only one person who has gone from a hospital to an inpatient rehab facility. It was my daughter-in-law after spinal surgery. It’s been my experience that you find somebody to care for you after you leave the hospital.

Miss Rosie’s Rehab

That “somebody” for me was Rosemary. We’re like sisters. We were in journalism school together at UNC-Chapel Hill, at each other’s wedding, and lived together in Greenville, SC, for our first jobs out of university. At the time of my accident, Rosemary was single. She lived on a farm with horses, donkeys, 3 dogs, and 20+ cats.

My us healthcare

Four-legged friends at Miss Rosey’s: Ester and her son, Firecracker

After my discharge from the hospital, no one talked about hiring an ambulance to take me home. Rosemary hauled me there in the backseat of her car. I’m unsure how we fit my 5’9″ broken body in the car, but we did it. Family members met us at my condo and put me into my bed. I could bear no weight on my left leg nor use my arm. I was fragile, and I was in a great deal of pain. Mind you, I had broken the femoral component of my hip into two pieces only five days earlier.

Patient Care

Rosemary was with me through one of my life’s most horrifically painful times. We stayed most of the time at her farm in North Carolina. Neither of us knew anything about tending to a patient after surgery.

My US Healthcare

View at Miss Rosey’s Rehab

Through trial and error, we discovered “tricks” to help us deal with the adversities of my lame condition and pain. For example, “How to move a lame patient in the bed.”

I’d experienced being pulled on a sheet from the stretcher to the X-ray table at the hospital. I asked the two female X-ray technicians, “How do you two manage to move a large man?

The same way,” they said.

So Rosemary always kept a folded sheet under me on the bed. When I needed to get out of bed, she’d pull the two corners of the folded sheet toward the side of the bed. Laying flat, my body would slide with the movement of the sheet to the edge of the mattress. Then, ever so slowly and gently, I’d sit up.

We used this routine day and night. Especially when I needed the toilet. It never dawned on us to use a bedpan.

For over six weeks, I moved from place to place at Miss Rosie’s with a walker. On one foot, with a broken arm. I was pretty much a prisoner in her guest room and kitchen. The floor plan of the house was multi-level.

One day we had the idea of using a kitchen stool to help me get to her deck outside. I sat on the stool in the kitchen. Then I swiveled my body around to face the kitchen door and the deck that was one step down. Rosemary took my walker onto the deck and Voila! I stepped off the stool on my one good leg, grabbed the walker, and was outside in the fresh air.

US Healthcare: Physical Therapy

When I felt ok to be alone, I left “Miss Rosey’s Rehab” and returned to South Carolina. I had to go back to work. Fortunately, I telecommuted from home with IBM, so there was no “going to the office.”

I began a twice-weekly regimen of physical therapy. My health insurance with IBM is allowed for 8 weeks. After 6 weeks, I had to stop. The pins in my hip were causing a problem. I waited until they were removed a month later to resume my treatment. Fortunately, IBM insurance paid for another 6 weeks of physical therapy.

The good news is that the physical therapy experience was excellent. I regained mobility and strength nearly one hundred percent.

US Healthcare: Costs

I wish I could recall the hospital and surgery cost eight years ago. I don’t remember how much I paid for health insurance. I do know, however, that I wasn’t on Medicare; I was covered by an employee policy provided by IBM, and I paid monthly for a supplemental insurance policy. The bottom line, I was well covered.

That means nothing now. With the cost of healthcare in the US today, whatever it cost in 2010 wouldn’t be relevant today.

Which is why I’m writing this post.

I’m writing this post because I think it’s essential to inform others about healthcare outside the US. As difficult as it is to believe, the US no longer has the best healthcare. (See below.)

Think of your experience in the US with hip surgery, back surgery, or any other condition requiring extended care. Compare it to what you read about my healthcare in France.


Over 28 Million Americans have no healthcare insurance.

The other day, I called a dear friend in the US who had expressed concern that I was staying in France after my accident. The first thing she told me when I called was that her son had been in an automobile accident. He was hospitalized with a crushed ankle, a broken leg, and a fractured wrist. After telling me about the car crash, we celebrated the fact that he had survived.

Then she revealed a horrible truth. Her son had no medical insurance. His policy had lapsed. A sad mistake too many of us make when we have busy lives.

As a result, my friend’s son was leaving the hospital after five days and two surgeries. He was going home to avoid the continuing hospital costs. He was barely conscious because of the massive doses of medication he needed for pain. He had a metal rod visibly running through his foot.

A third surgery is scheduled in two weeks. He’ll go to the hospital, then back home after surgery. No trained medical person will stay with him when he requires intensive care and pain management. The entire family will need to chip in with time off work as they can.

US Healthcare: 3 Reasons We Deserve Better

#1 Worst Healthcare in the Developed World

The state of healthcare in the US is alarming. Once a leader, US Healthcare is Ranked the Worst in the Developed World.My us healthcare

#2 Cost is Prohibitive

The cost of healthcare is prohibitive for many, especially those without insurance or with poor coverage; #3 Healthcare Costs are Bankrupting America

Healthcare is the #1 cause of bankruptcy in the US today.

My us healthcareI read a statement recently that I can’t get out of my head. A young girl who was returning home to France after two years in the US as an au pair was asked:

“Would you like to stay in the US?”

To the interviewer’s surprise, she replied, “No,” and continued, “The US doesn’t take care of its people.”

My us health care


French Healthcare for Expats?

Renestance, an American-staffed relocation company in Montpelier, has produced an excellent series of ebooks on Healthcare in France. Check out their website for all types of guidance for expats.

Categories: Around France

Tagged as: ,

17 replies »

  1. Debby, how are you doing now? I have been thinking about you and wonder if you are walking yet. Also, will you be able to leave rehab by end of month. Let me know what is happening with you.

  2. I’ve had to see doctors several times while living in France, for various cuts and breaks, and each time my experience was excellent. And the costs (when I had to pay) were minimal: $30-40 for an office visit, $25 for an X-ray. I also had physical therapy once and it was $16 for each hour-long session. I had similar experiences with the medical system when I lived and worked in Switzerland, except then all the costs were fully covered through a combination of government and company-paid insurance.

    The quality of care I received in France and Switzerland, in terms of the competence of the medical professionals, was comparable to that in the US. If I had a condition that required cutting-edge treatment, say the latest cancer therapy, I would want to be in the US where such therapies are often first developed. But for most things, I’m happy to see a doctor in France or Switzerland or, I would imagine, a number of other countries.

    • I can’t believe how well I’ve been treated in the hospital and rehab hospitals. It makes me sad the same is not available in the US to the average person. There’s a lot of work to be done to bring down costs and change the system. A lot of good people are involved in health care in the US. It must be difficult for them to survive with dignity within such a broken industry. My mother was an anesthetist way back when. She would be heartbroken. Thanks for the note, Keith.

  3. Thank you for sharing your story! I’m a physical therapist assistant at an out patient clinic in Michigan. Many people can’t afford therapy because their co-pays and deductibles are too high. Which is unfortunate, because therapy is better than drugs. Looks like you’re on the road to recovery and healing well. Best of luck to you.

    • I searched for someone who could validate my thoughts that physical therapy is out if reach cost wise for too many. It certainly has helped me. I’m looking forward to beginning the next phase now that the surgeon has said I can bear weight on my leg and make vet my arm and shoulder. Thank you for your wonderful work, Stacy. My daughter-in-law now walks thanks to gifted therapists.

  4. Did it take you long to walk when you broke your hip last time? I cannot believe you have had this happen twice!! You must be anxious to start weight bearing.

    • It seemed forever before I could walk again without aid. I had to learn you roll your foot when walking. Stairs were a nightmare. Just thinking of my stairs now makes me cringe. But this too shall pass🌈

      • Oh, those stairs to your lovely apartment. Certainly the challenge is on. If anyone is up to a challenge it is you.

  5. Very informative article based on your personal experience. I’ve experienced healthcare in a variety of countries having lived and worked on 4 continents over the past 15 years. The best care I’ve had was when I was hospitalized twice in Bangkok, Thailand, and at a fraction of the cost of hospitalization in the USA. At the same time costs have soared in the USA, the quality of care has risen in many other parts of the world making medical tourism a rapidly growing industry.

    As a university lecturer teaching abroad, I’ve also worked with many expats from the UK, Canada, Australia and other countries that have simplified medical care via a simpler, more transparent system where costs are capped and everyone receives equal treatment. Not a single one of these expats has had any complaints about the medical care in their home countries, while at the same time, they feel sympathy for Americans who are forced to bear the burden of high costs and a system so fragmented that even the smallest doctor’s office must employ multiple people just to deal with insurance claims. “Broken” is the only word I can come up with that seems to describe the current state of medical care in the USA.

    Thanks for your post!

    • Thank you, Henry, for your comment. I’m so happy to hear from others who have had similar experiences, albeit in different countries. It seems the world is connected enough now that we could learn from each other. Perhaps “each one teaches one,”

  6. Fortunately I have had excellent healthcare experiences in the US. So it is hard to generalize that it is all bad. But I do wonder…who pays for the healthcare in France.

    • Pat, I hope I didn’t imply my US healthcare was all bad. There is just a different philosophy about treating patients, especially after surgeries. In France they believe all people have a right to healthcare. The people of France pay for healthcare through taxes. Just as in the US, nothing is free. The French, however don’t have the high costs of the US. Largely because doctors and hospitals aren’t spending billions on legal fees and insurance. The costs of drugs, surgeries and care are minimal compared to the US. It’s not a perfect system here. The French complain about their high taxes. But they are proud, also, of their healthcare and public education. Interestingly, they make only generic drugs available if there is one. For example, I had to switch from Throxin to Levothyroxin. The pharmacist said the non-generic is no longer sold in France. Government control may not be good for everyone and everything, but it seems to be working in health are here. Btw, I do pay tax here and in the US.

  7. Such an excellent and informative article, Deborah! I abslutely agree with you as to where I would rather be in your situation! The individualism and “You’re on your own” attidude in the US currently compares very poorly with the sense of community and equal access to health care – rich or poor, immigrant or not, all get the care they need. Get profit out of US medical care!

    • I could have added that I met a young man from Nigeria in the hospital. He has no Visa, yet he received the identical good service as I did. It’s the humane thing to do. Thanks for your comment and for following BFB.

      • I’m being taken by ambulance to the hospital in Nimes on Tuesday for X-rays and to see the surgeon. Hopefully all will be healing enough that I can begin to put weight on my left leg. Them I can start to relearn to walk. The shoulder won’t be as quick. It’ll be fine. You know I love attention. 😘

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.